Don Mattingly

The Phillies Looked at a Broad Manager Search and Said "Nah, We're Good"

Remember last week, when the Phillies got publicly turned down by Alex Cora and we all braced for a long, dramatic manager search full of mystery candidates and burner-account speculation? Cancel the bracket. According to The Athletic's Matt Gelb and Charlotte Varnes, the Phillies are keeping Don Mattingly — the interim tag comes off, he manages in 2027, and the big offseason question got answered before anyone finished asking it. The team hasn't formalized it yet, hasn't even held its end-of-season press availability, but the search is reportedly over. It ended where it started: in the dugout.

Donnie Baseball, No Longer a Placeholder

Let's be fair before we're Philly about it. Mattingly took over in April when Rob Thomson got fired, went 79-55 the rest of the way, and steered a team mid-managerial-crisis to another NL East flag. That's a real resume line. The man stabilized a season that could have gone sideways, and the front office clearly values the part where the clubhouse didn't combust.

Now the Philly part: this is also the manager whose October ended in three games, with a Game 1 loss that featured Jhoan Duran pitching the seventh inning — a decision that's still being litigated on every barstool from Fishtown to Delco. A PhillyVoice reader poll had 59% wanting to move on. And the timeline tells you something, too: with an owner-imposed work stoppage expected to start December 2, the Phillies wanted this settled fast rather than running the sprawling search everybody expected. Cora said no (he's reportedly taking 2027 off entirely), the lockout clock was ticking, and the path of least resistance was wearing number 8 in the dugout the whole time. Sometimes "the guy we already have" is a baseball decision, and sometimes it's a calendar decision. This one looks like both, and we're allowed to feel both ways about it.

The contract could reportedly get amended to add a year, and the coaching staff could still be shuffled. So there's your offseason intrigue, downgraded from "who manages this team" to "who coaches first base." Thrilling stuff. Wake us up when the lockout ends.

The Flyers Lost Again, But This Time It Made Us Feel Something

Meanwhile, at Xfinity Mobile Arena, the Flyers lost their eighth straight to open the season — 3-2 to the Kraken in a shootout — and somehow it was the most alive this team has looked all year. Down 2-0 in the third, they got a Christian Dvorak goal and then a Trevor Zegras equalizer at 4-on-4, dragged the defending road-warrior Kraken to a shootout, and Dan Vladar stopped 29 shots plus a Jordan Eberle penalty shot for good measure. Matvei Michkov scored in the shootout; nobody else did; Bobby McMann ended it in the fifth round. 0-5-3, the worst season-opening skid since the 2024-25 Sharks, and ten goals in eight games.

But here's your silver lining, and it's got gloves at the end of it: Zegras spent the second period trying to jam a puck out from under Philipp Grubauer, took a slash call for it, and then stood there shoving the goalie while the whistles blew. His postgame review? "I think maybe we just need a little bit more of that in our DNA going forward." Trevor. Buddy. Welcome to Philadelphia — the lease is signed, you live here now. Even Tocchet, seven losses deep into "Fire Tocchet" chants, called it the best he's seen Zegras play. The Hurricanes' tweet remains legally binding for now, but a team that was getting run out of buildings by three goals just scrapped for a point against the defending champs' little brother. It's not a win. It's a pulse. We'll take the pulse.

Next chance: Thursday night in Detroit, 7:30. Win one, and the first round at the bar is metaphorically on us.

Actual Good News, Courtesy of the Eagles Training Room

And in today's edition of "things we're afraid to say out loud": Nick Sirianni says he's hopeful Saquon Barkley and DeVonta Smith return Sunday against the Panthers. Both hamstrings, both out since the Rams game, both sorely missed by an offense that just went 21-of-40 in London without them. Wednesday's practice is the first real clue, so keep an eye on the report — but a 2-3 team getting its All-Pro back and its best route-runner back for a home get-right game is the closest thing to a gift this sports city has received in October.

Temper it with the fine print: Will Shipley has a partial plantar fascia tear and could miss multiple weeks, Tank Bigsby's on IR, and the healthy running back room behind a maybe-Saquon is Dameon Pierce and Carson Steele. So yes, hopeful. Philadelphia hopeful. Hopeful with a helmet on.

The Assignment

Thursday, 7:30: Flyers at Red Wings — somebody win a hockey game before this becomes a lifestyle. Friday the Sixers get their Boston rematch at the Wells Fargo Center, with opening night at MSG looming Tuesday. Sunday, 1:00, the Linc: Eagles-Panthers, possibly with Saquon and Smitty back in the huddle, definitely with a home-win drought that needs to die.

Closet logistics: Football collection for Sunday — the Linc hasn't seen a win since September and that's everyone's problem to fix, including yours. And if you're pouring one for Donnie Baseball tonight, the whole shop is open. Running it back is very on-brand for us, too.

Eight straight losses, one retained manager, two hamstrings on the mend. In this city, that's called a Wednesday.

Go Birds. Go Flyers. Go... Donnie?

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.